---
title: Exclusive vs multi-source procurement
url: "https://www.wiima.com/articles/exclusive-vs-multi-source-choosing-the-right-transportation-procurement-strategy-for-your-business/"
lang: en
page_type: page
source: "https://www.wiima.com/articles/exclusive-vs-multi-source-choosing-the-right-transportation-procurement-strategy-for-your-business/"
---
# Exclusive vs multi-source procurement

*2024-11-15*

One carrier or several? Your procurement strategy affects price, risk and workload. Here's how to choose between exclusive sourcing and multi-sourcing.

One carrier or several? Your procurement strategy affects price, risk and workload. Here's how to choose between exclusive sourcing and multi-sourcing.

## What is transportation procurement?

Transportation procurement is selecting and contracting with carriers to move your goods. This includes everything from negotiating rates and service levels to managing contracts and ensuring on-time delivery. Choosing the right procurement strategy can significantly impact your transportation costs, efficiency, and overall supply chain success.

## Exclusive sourcing: all your eggs in one basket

In an exclusive sourcing strategy, you partner with a single carrier to handle all your transportation needs. This approach offers several potential benefits:

- **Simplified management:** Dealing with one carrier reduces administrative burden and can streamline communication and simplify logistics coordination.

- **Potential for volume discounts:** If you are a high-volume shipper, it can unlock lower rates for your business.

- **Building strong relationships:** Building a strong relationship with a single carrier can lead to improved service and responsiveness to your specific needs.

However, exclusive sourcing also comes with drawbacks:

- **Increased risk:** If your carrier experiences delays or disruptions, your entire operation can be impacted.

- **Limited flexibility:** One carrier can't be the best option for every lane and shipment type.

- **Less competitive pressure:** Without alternative bids, it is harder to benchmark the rate.

- **Vendor lock-in:** Switching carriers in the future can be complex and time-consuming.

## Multi-sourcing: spreading the risk

The multi-source approach involves contracting with multiple carriers for your transportation needs. Benefits include:

- **Flexibility:** If one carrier experiences issues, you can rely on alternative providers to keep your shipments moving.

- **Competitive rates:** Soliciting bids from multiple carriers creates a competitive environment, potentially leading to lower overall transportation costs.

- **Specialised expertise:** You can leverage different carriers’ strengths to handle various shipment types or geographical regions.

However, multi-sourcing also presents challenges:

- **Increased management complexity:** Coordinating with multiple carriers can be more time-consuming and require a robust logistics management system.

- **Lower negotiation power with individual carriers:** As a smaller customer to each carrier, you might have less leverage during rate negotiations.

- **Maintaining relationships:** Building and maintaining strong relationships with multiple carriers requires more effort.

## Choosing the right strategy: it depends on your needs

There’s no one-size-fits-all answer when it comes to transportation procurement. The best strategy depends on your specific needs and business priorities. Consider factors like:

- **Shipment volume:** High-volume businesses may benefit more from negotiated discounts offered by exclusive sourcing.

- **Complexity of transportation needs:** Specialised cargo or “exotic” locations might require a multi-source approach to leverage carriers with expertise in specific handling or regions.

- **Risk tolerance:** Businesses with high reliance on timely deliveries might require the flexibility offered by multi-sourcing.

- **Cost sensitivity:** Focus on competitive and transparent pricing might push you towards multi-sourcing.

## How can Wiima help?

At Wiima, we believe in fair competition, so our default is multi-sourcing. That is partly due to the varied needs of logistics management amongst our customer base, but largely it is just to get the prices right. When an exclusive contract suits a customer better, we use one.

With [Wiima iControl](/icontrol/), we have made it easy to operate in a multi-source environment. It compares transport rate cards, then books, tracks and reports in one view.

[Contact us](/contact-us/) to find the right sourcing model for you.
