Logistics market update – 15 February 2024

January air volumes rose on the Red Sea crisis and the approach of Chinese New Year, while average rates still fell. Ocean carriers returned to profit on surcharges, European roads faced protests, and rail bookings jumped.

This is the market excerpt from 15 February 2024. Later updates are listed with the newest first.

Air freight

The air freight industry experienced a notable increase in volumes this January, primarily influenced by the ongoing Red Sea crisis and the approach of Chinese New Year. Despite this surge in demand, average rates showed a downward trend.

Data from Xeneta revealed a significant 10% year-on-year rise in global air cargo volumes last month, indicating a robust start to the year. FourKites also reported a substantial increase in tracked air freight shipments since mid-January. However, abundant capacity on dedicated freighters and in passenger-aircraft bellies has meant that these higher volumes have not yet resulted in increased rates. January’s general air cargo spot rates saw a 12% drop from the previous month, averaging $2.27 per kg.

Demand for air freight is growing, particularly on routes where multimodal and sea-air transport can mitigate delays caused by the Red Sea situation. Hubs like Singapore, Dubai (Jebel Ali) and Seattle are seeing heightened activity, with Jebel Ali emerging as a critical node for sea-air connections.

Despite the volume increase, January traditionally sees less pressure on capacity, which explains the lack of significant rate hikes. However, some specific air cargo spot rates have risen, particularly from north-east Asia to Europe, reaching $3.42 per kg in late January. This spike may be linked to e-commerce demand, with companies like Shein and Temu contributing significantly to air freight volumes.

While traditional air cargo sectors faced challenges in 2023, e-commerce remained robust. E-commerce will continue to drive air cargo in 2024, potentially accounting for a significant portion of total tonnage.

The air freight industry has recently grown more adaptable to market volatility, moving from seasonal rate setting to more dynamic pricing. This shift is evident in the industry’s response to the Red Sea crisis but also reflects broader trends in air cargo. A potential normalisation in both air and ocean volumes and rates is expected after February, provided market stability returns.

Our suggestions

  • Capitalise on dynamic pricing. With air freight rates showing a downward trend despite volume increases, companies should use dynamic pricing models to secure competitive rates.
  • Use established sea-air hubs. Use hubs such as Dubai (Jebel Ali) and Singapore to avoid Red Sea delays.
  • Explore sea-air multimodal solutions. To circumvent delays from the Red Sea situation, consider sea-air solutions that offer a balance between cost and speed.
  • Invest in e-commerce capabilities. Given the robust growth in e-commerce driving air cargo volumes, stronger e-commerce logistics capabilities can position companies to take advantage of this trend.

Sea freight

After a challenging final quarter in 2023, ocean carriers have already rebounded into profitability this year, thanks to significant rate hikes and surcharges in response to supply chain disruptions due to the Red Sea crisis. However, the sustainability of these profits remains in question, particularly given the ongoing issue of overcapacity and the longer transit times required for detours around the Cape of Good Hope.

Also, the spot rates from Asia to Europe have recently seen a dip, as transpacific rates are now gradually stabilising. This indicates the start of a downward trend in rates. Despite this decline, rates in both trading lanes remain substantially higher than historical norms.

The usual pre-Chinese New Year surge is muted and will be followed by a quieter period for Chinese exporters in late February, leaving capacity unused. Analysts believe the peak impact of the Red Sea disruption may have passed, so rates could ease.

Year-on-year comparisons show a significant rate increase, influencing the coming transpacific contract negotiations. After Chinese New Year, a further reduction in spot rates is anticipated, although they are unlikely to revert to levels seen before the recent crisis because the rate adjustment will likely include the added costs of longer shipping routes and a rebalancing of supply and demand.

On the transatlantic route, attempts by carriers to boost rates have not been successful, with average rates remaining relatively low. This suggests a different market dynamic compared with the Asia–Europe and transpacific lanes.

Our suggestions

  • Evaluate contracts and negotiate flexibility. Given fluctuating spot rates and the potential easing of rates, review contracts with ocean carriers. Flexibility in rate adjustments and surcharge applications could save cost over the term of the deal.
  • Diversify shipping routes and carriers. To mitigate risks associated with the Red Sea crisis and overcapacity, diversifying routes and carriers could support more stable operations.
  • Monitor rate trends closely. With the expectation of rate adjustments after Chinese New Year, monitor trends to identify better booking windows.
  • Use the spot market opportunistically. The dip in spot rates offers short-term cost savings, while long-term contracts still provide stability.
  • Plan for capacity fluctuations. Anticipate unused capacity after Chinese New Year to avoid being caught by the next rate move.

Road freight

The European road freight sector faces a rough start to the year, marked by widespread protests and regulatory delays. The World Road Transport Organisation (IRU) has highlighted growing concerns over the free movement of goods as farmers and truckers across the EU stage protests. France and Germany are experiencing significant disruptions, with roadblocks threatening the timely delivery of essential goods like food and medicine.

These protests, driven by demands for fair pricing and opposition to environmental legislation, highlight deeper issues within the road freight industry, including driver safety. Recent tragic incidents, like a fatal crash at a French roadblock, have raised alarms about the security of both drivers and the public.

Amidst these disruptions, the European Union’s decision to postpone new sustainability reporting standards until 2026 has sparked criticism. The delay in implementing the Corporate Sustainability Reporting Directive (CSRD), which mandates companies to report emissions data, is seen as a setback in the fight against climate change. Critics argue that such delays hinder meaningful progress in decarbonising one of the largest emitting sectors.

The CSRD aims to promote transparency in emissions reporting, including Scope 1, 2 and 3 emissions. However, with the proposed postponement, sectors like road transport will have extended leeway before they need to comply with these reporting standards.

The road freight industry in the EU faces the dual pressures of adapting to immediate operational disruptions and preparing for long-term sustainability commitments.

Our suggestions

  • Plan for disruptions. With ongoing protests and regulatory delays, plan operations to account for potential disruption, especially in hotspot areas like France and Germany.
  • Engage in sustainability planning. Despite the delay in the CSRD, start planning for eventual compliance by assessing and reducing emissions within logistics operations.
  • Prioritise driver safety and compliance. In light of safety concerns, prioritise partnerships with road transport providers that demonstrate strong commitments to driver safety and regulatory compliance.

Rail freight

In response to the ongoing Red Sea crisis, the rail freight industry is experiencing a notable shift in transport preferences. Dimerco reports a significant 30% jump in rail volumes year on year, with enquiries for rail bookings surging by 40% in recent months.

Amplified by the Chinese New Year rush, this reflects a pivot to rail amid global shipping uncertainties. While less-than-container load (LCL) rail shipments have seen substantial volume increases, full-container loads (FCL) are yet to match this growth. With ocean rates elevated by Red Sea diversions, some shippers report rail pricing closing the gap versus sea on selected China–Europe lanes.

The shift is not uniform across all markets due to geopolitical factors like the Ukraine conflict. For instance, sanctions affecting specific routes through Russia limit options for EU and US customers. Although alternatives like the Black Sea route exist, they are less attractive due to longer transit times and higher costs. However, in Asia and developing regions, rail continues to be a viable option, with Xi’an, a major China–Europe rail hub, seeing a 15.3% increase in departures in 2023.

The rail sector anticipates further growth in the near future, with plans to increase train departures significantly in 2024. As the holiday period looms, rail spot rates are rising, although availability varies by route. For now, rail transport is a resilient and increasingly favoured mode of transportation amid global logistical challenges.

Our suggestions

  • Shift to rail where feasible. With rail volumes increasing and costs comparable to elevated ocean rates, consider shifting more freight to rail, especially for routes less affected by geopolitical issues.
  • Book in advance to secure capacity. Given the surge in rail bookings and anticipated further growth, secure capacity by booking in advance, especially for peak periods.
  • Assess route viability regularly. Continuously assess the viability of rail routes, especially considering geopolitical factors affecting routes through Russia and alternatives like the Black Sea route.

Is a 4PL model relevant for you?

We will review your current logistics together and see where 4PL management could help.