Logistics market update – 16 April 2024

Air freight demand kept growing after Chinese New Year, ocean rates are easing, the EU–Moldova road deal is extended and German rail faces new surcharges.

This is the market excerpt from 16 April 2024. Later updates are listed with the newest first.

Air freight

Air freight has sustained its momentum beyond Chinese New Year and seen a clear uplift in demand and spot rates. Following January’s robust performance, February showcased a consecutive month of double-digit growth in demand, with an 11% year-on-year increase, defying the traditional post-CNY slowdown. This surge has increased the average global cargo spot rate by 2% from January, reaching $2.29 per kg.

This unexpected uptick is largely attributed to the logistical turmoil unleashed by the Red Sea crisis, which has dented ocean schedule reliability, which fell to just 39.4% in January – the lowest since October 2022 – nudging shippers towards sea-air or pure air freight. The ripple effects have boosted volumes at key Asia–Europe sea-air hubs. Dubai, Colombo and Bangkok have reported year-on-year increases in air cargo tonnages to Europe, with growth rates of 71%, 61% and 58% respectively in the first seven weeks of 2024.

Despite declining revenues in 2023 – as rates normalised after the pandemic-era peak – stakeholders remain optimistic about the sector’s trajectory in 2024. Lufthansa and Etihad, for instance, witnessed a sharp revenue downturn last year but are now eyeing a promising uptick, driven by e-commerce growth and ongoing disruption in ocean freight. Lufthansa Cargo’s revenue dipped to €2.98bn ($3.3bn) in 2023, marking a 36% decrease from 2022, while Etihad’s cargo revenues fell by 38% year on year to $914m. However, as evidenced by nearly parallel tonnage figures year on year, the underlying demand metrics point towards a market recalibration rather than a downturn in demand as such.

Red Sea disruption continues to inject volatility into global trade routes, which keeps air freight in play as an alternative. E-commerce demand from China also needs freight capacity. Carriers are adjusting networks around those two facts rather than around a single seasonal peak.

Our suggestions

  • Capitalise on air freight’s reliability. Shift more volume to air freight where time sensitivity or supply chain disruptions justify the higher cost, especially while sea freight remains volatile.
  • Partner with reliable airlines. Establish relationships with airlines known for reliability and capacity, ensuring priority access in peak times.
  • Monitor market trends. Stay informed about air cargo dynamics to adapt to rate changes and capacity issues, particularly during events that affect traditional freight modes.

Road freight

The EU and Moldova have agreed to extend their road transport agreement until 31 December 2025, reinforcing economic ties and easing transit between the EU and Moldova. Originally signed on 29 June 2022, this agreement has notably boosted Moldova’s exports to the EU, benefiting both economies amid challenging global conditions. The extension aims to maintain and further develop Moldova’s integration with the EU market, especially after losing critical transport routes through Ukraine due to the conflict with Russia. Liberalising road freight and granting transport rights supports the EU–Ukraine Solidarity Lanes, enhancing connectivity and facilitating Ukrainian trade through Moldova.

Significant growth has been observed in road exports from Moldova to the EU, with a 27% increase in volume in Q3 2022 and a 35% increase in Q3 2023 compared with 2021. The EU has also seen a positive impact, with a 30% rise in road exports to Moldova by value from Q3 2021 to Q3 2022, stabilising in the same period in 2023. The extension of this agreement, confirmed at the latest Joint Committee meeting, promises continued economic collaboration without altering the original terms, aiming to strengthen the logistical and economic bond between the EU and Moldova.

Our suggestions

  • Maximise regional agreements. Use extended road transport agreements, such as between the EU and Moldova, to enhance connectivity and reduce transit times for European operations.
  • Focus on border efficiency. Optimise logistics planning around border crossings and customs clearance to benefit from smoother road freight operations.
  • Strategic route planning. Use route planning to avoid congested routes and capitalise on liberalised road freight markets.

Sea freight

Transpacific and Asia–Europe container spot rates remained higher than a year earlier in April, but the Asia–Europe lane was declining faster, compelling carriers to adjust their FAK rates for April. Hapag-Lloyd and MSC have published new FAK rates to counterbalance the rapid erosion of revenue. Despite these adjustments, Drewry’s WCI indicates that current spot rates for North Europe and the Mediterranean are yet to meet Hapag-Lloyd’s revised FAK rates, highlighting a potential further decline by May due to subdued demand.

The backdrop of these fluctuations is the ongoing Red Sea crisis, which has caused disruptions and rerouting around the Cape of Good Hope. These events have notably impacted European exporters to the Middle East and the Indian subcontinent, leading to a pivot towards Far East suppliers. Maritime consultancy MSI notes a 34.5% expansion in the Far East–Middle East/India trade in January, driven by India’s burgeoning demand for containerised imports.

Our suggestions

  • Flexibility in contracting. Negotiate contracts with built-in flexibility such as adjustable rates and terms, especially given the variability in rates.
  • Explore alternative ports and carriers. Diversify import and export routes and use multiple carriers to avoid dependency on a single route or provider.
  • Leverage 4PL expertise. Use fourth-party logistics (4PL) providers to handle complex routing and increased compliance needs.

Rail freight

In a notable shift for German rail freight, Maersk has introduced a €9 ($9.73) per TEU rail infrastructure surcharge from 1 April, in response to reduced state subsidies for rail paths within Germany. This surcharge is a direct consequence of the cut in Trassenförderung, a vital government subsidy, which has been scaled back by €120m from its previous €350m.

This development introduces new cost pressures for shippers and adds to the uncertainty surrounding the future of European rail freight, especially as it is considered crucial for achieving the EU’s net-zero targets.

Amid these changes, the potential restructuring of DB Cargo looms, sparked by concerns over government support leading to market distortion. This situation echoes France’s approach with Fret SNCF, which was restructured to avoid European Commission sanctions for unfair state aid.

Despite the challenges, private rail operators in Germany, holding around 59% market share by 2022, demonstrate the sector’s resilience and competitive edge. Their success without state financing underscores a robust market that can sustain fair competition and innovation. As Germany adjusts to these regulatory and operational shifts, rail freight remains central to a more efficient European logistics network.

Our suggestions

  • Evaluate cost implications. Account for new surcharges and cost adjustments in rail freight, especially in Europe, by updating budget allocations and contract terms.
  • Favour rail where possible. Use rail as part of a sustainability strategy, aligning with broader corporate goals for reducing carbon footprint.
  • Prepare for regulatory changes. Stay updated on government policies and subsidies affecting rail infrastructure and pricing, particularly in Germany, where policy shifts can change costs.

Is a 4PL model relevant for you?

We will review your current logistics together and see where 4PL management could help.